The Soapbox

Joined: 01/04/2001 Posts: 26993
Likes: 34246

What's this?

If you really wanted to see such arguments, you could find them in under

a minute, just by googling "why the US needs illegal immigrants". I linked one for you, but you can find any number of arguments on your own.

Of course, that's not really the purpose of your post - you don't need me to link this for you. You wanted to change the subject. The subject wasn't "I think we need illegal immigrants, and here's why". It was "when deporting parents from whom small children were removed, what was the plan to reunite the families"? Because it sure looks like there wasn't one. If I were a Trumpie, I'd hate that question too.

All Americans, one would think, are united in their revulsion to the idea of small children being forcibly removed from their parents with no plan for the well being of those children. Where these kids go does not appear to be well tracked, the press and even senior members of govt have been barred from entering and documenting the facilities they're kept in, and the govt can't even comply with a court order to reunite these families by this week, calling into question whether there was ever an intention to reunite these families. Most Americans would associate that treatment of minors with evil regimes, perhaps in a movie where The Rock or Jason Statham or some other action hero saves the day, kills the bad guys, and reunites kids with families. Most American wouldn't want their president being the bad guy in that movie. Before Trump, I'd have said "all Americans", but now there's as much as 30% who will defend anything this guy does.

Including this - something that would be clear cut "wrong" in the black and white world of right and wrong. So I understand your refusal to even address the question of this thread, because none of the answers look too good for Trump, so you may as well just deflect to some other question.

(In response to this post by TomKazanski)

Link: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/america-needs-more-workers-trumps-war-on-immigration-wont-help/2018/04/08/537c9926-3916-11e8-acd5-35eac230e514_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.3dcff6547920

Posted: 07/09/2018 at 1:05PM

PREV NEXT REPLY

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:

Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:

Current Thread:

If parents deported, what was to happen to their small children? -- WarmHoo 07/09/2018 10:53AM

Kept as hostages for votes in Congress and the UN** -- NJHoo 07/09/2018 4:06PM

Well, the US government argued in court Friday that it should not be -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 2:24PM

Soylent Green ** -- Mad Bowl Hoo 07/09/2018 11:58AM

Collagen source for trumps. ** -- KCHoo 07/09/2018 1:32PM

Yes, but marketed as Soylent Brown. ** -- hooyorkcity 07/09/2018 12:48PM

Sick, but in a funny kind of way. ** -- graycalhoo 07/09/2018 12:10PM

It reminds me of the underpants gnomes from South Park -- WahooMatt05 07/09/2018 11:22AM

The plan was to separate to deter. That's it. ** -- Hooddihsm 07/09/2018 11:05AM

Exactly what I think. -- hoolstoptheheels 07/09/2018 1:25PM

Yep. Effective, but brutal. And also discouraging the immigration that -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 11:19AM

Because Blue Collar America is dying out -- Beerman 07/09/2018 1:07PM

And why cant you libs understand that we want legal immigration? Come here -- SokurHoo83 07/09/2018 11:49AM

Because many of you don't -- Beerman 07/09/2018 1:50PM

Nope...legally...not sneaking in. This isn't difficult. ** -- SokurHoo83 07/09/2018 2:48PM

Trump wants to reduce LEGAL immigration -- southdenverhoo 07/09/2018 3:46PM

Could you point to the policies specifically targeting brown people -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 3:52PM

I’ll get back to you when I have a bit more time -- southdenverhoo 07/09/2018 3:59PM

Oh sadly there probably is support for it even if the policies don't -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 4:17PM

Maybe not official, but to support "wants" is the s-hole comment. ** -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 4:15PM

Many of you don't want that. Fear of more Dem voters seems to -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 3:01PM

And on the flip side...excitement of more Dem voters seems to -- Hoo23 07/09/2018 3:41PM

Nah, it’s mostly that Statue of Liberty shit. -- southdenverhoo 07/09/2018 3:50PM

Some of the many ways the Trump admin is reducing legal immigration: -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 1:03PM

For the first time, U.S. resettles fewer refugees than the rest (link) -- Hoo TV 07/09/2018 4:03PM

They aren't and can't "end chain migration". They only want to limit it to -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 2:37PM

Fair enough -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 6:17PM

No need to re-word, plenty of idiots on right shout "end chain migration" -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 6:47PM

These illegals just need to brush up on their immigration law -- WahooMatt05 07/09/2018 1:26PM

As long as they're from Norway. -- Shenhoo 07/09/2018 12:52PM

Uh, then why did the GOP DACA fix try to cut legal immigration in half? -- WahooMatt05 07/09/2018 11:56AM

At least get your numbers right... ** -- SokurHoo83 07/09/2018 12:47PM

Because libs have left a mess with their stupidity -- TomKazanski 07/09/2018 12:40PM

Correct. The actions speak so loudly I can't hear a word they're saying. ** -- Seattle .Hoo 07/09/2018 12:29PM

First, it wasn't half, more like 25%. Second what does that have to do with -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 12:09PM

Why is the administration then now forcing immigrant military service -- Seattle .Hoo 07/09/2018 12:28PM

"denaturalize and deport people who are already citizens?" Got a link? Damn -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 12:58PM

Here you go. As if you couldn't do this for yourself. -- Seattle .Hoo 07/09/2018 1:02PM

OMG! F Trump! I should've Stood with Her! That f'er wants to denaturalize -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 2:05PM

Another way to look at it... -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 3:15PM

The first article did address that, and I think that's the folks in charge -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 3:40PM

I guess it's a good thing Jared Kushner didn't have to fill out those forms -- WahooMatt05 07/09/2018 1:43PM

If you can’t come up with a better whataboutism than that you should quit ** -- Cold Hoober Hoo 07/09/2018 5:12PM

Not every joke's a winner -- WahooMatt05 07/09/2018 5:19PM

Mistakes? You guys sure do have a way with softening the language -- Cold Hoober Hoo 07/09/2018 5:54PM

Did he do so on his immigration application? Oh wait, that doesn't apply -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 2:11PM

Is it conclusive they are doing that? The article I saw talked about 40 -- BocaHoo91 07/09/2018 12:43PM

Things start small. The article I read stated that the government was using -- Seattle .Hoo 07/09/2018 1:10PM

FYI he's addressing military discharges, you're talking green card holders -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 1:37PM

Labor protectionism doesn't work in the long run. There -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 12:14PM

Since FICA taxes are a percentage of payroll, and we need those folks to -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 12:42PM

Disparaging farm work now? What other work do you consider menial? ** -- Seattle .Hoo 07/09/2018 1:11PM

Not at all, other than alleged lawyers living in their Arlington McMansions -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 1:35PM

Those aren’t the choices, but you know that. ** -- southdenverhoo 07/09/2018 4:10PM

Whirling dervish of nonsensical gobbledygook. Thanks again, Schm. ** -- WahooRQ 07/09/2018 1:37PM

Are those college graduate and post graduate degree holders going to pick -- Hooddihsm 07/09/2018 12:13PM

And if they don't, we might have to pay our lettuce pickers more so that -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 12:37PM

Did you pick up a meth habit in the last year or so? ** -- WahooRQ 07/09/2018 1:17PM

Your last sentence is unbelievably delusional. -- Hooddihsm 07/09/2018 12:42PM

Why is that delusional? Other than apparently making me a cult member. Or -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 1:26PM

We don’t need any illegal immigration. I have yet to see anyone -- TomKazanski 07/09/2018 11:48AM

If you really wanted to see such arguments, you could find them in under -- hoolstoptheheels 07/09/2018 1:05PM

I think Tom has unwittingly exposed the real reason. Seriously. -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 12:19PM

Illegals are by far a net negative, again I’m waiting for first coherent -- TomKazanski 07/09/2018 12:39PM

Illegals work but don't vote -- if the opposite weren’t true for your -- WahooRQ 07/09/2018 12:50PM

I'm arguing to make them legal, but I know you and the GOP don't -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 12:42PM

Trump offered you making 1.6M of them legal and giving them a path to -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 2:20PM

The House "compromise bill" only got yea votes from 51% -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 3:03PM

Oh I know, it was pathetic and disappointing, although predicted. So I -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 3:31PM

The Schumer thing was related to the government shutdown in January -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 6:10PM

Because rednecks like you are too lazy and entitled to pick avocados and -- WahooRQ 07/09/2018 11:52AM

Come on now. Tom would do it, but it's way above his skill/cognitive level. ** -- hooyorkcity 07/09/2018 12:39PM

Do not like the red neck comment, but -- VaTechie 07/09/2018 12:30PM

These guys know their audience: low-information white people without a -- WahooRQ 07/09/2018 11:45AM

This reminded me of something I saw the other day... -- 00 Hoo 07/09/2018 1:46PM

But if they were legal, their pay would go up. ** -- Lazarus 07/09/2018 11:43AM

And they would be paying taxes. ** -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 12:14PM

Just import them as needed like Trump at Mar-a-Lago (link) -- Hoo TV 07/09/2018 11:37AM

Talk about irony. ** -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 2:58PM

But I guess the economy can just be fixed with tariffs and tax cuts. ** -- HoosWillWin 07/09/2018 11:20AM

What we see is the plan. Anyone Hoo sez otherwise is a liar or a fool** -- WaxHoo 07/09/2018 11:01AM

I think this is what they wanted -- wahoo138 07/09/2018 11:00AM

LOL! Of course it was. There's nothing we want more than wards of the state -- Hoodafan 07/09/2018 11:55AM

Tender Kare Kennels. ** -- Shenhoo 07/09/2018 10:58AM